Looking to limit birthright citizenship, Trump turns to an 1884 Supreme Court ruling against a Native American man - nbcnews.com
Quick Insights
The Bottom Line
President Trump is pursuing limits on birthright citizenship using an 1884 Supreme Court ruling that denied Native American citizenship.
How This Affects You
Changes to birthright citizenship could affect citizenship status of children born to non-citizen parents in the U.S., potentially creating stateless individuals or requiring renunciation of automatic citizenship claims.
AI Summary
President Trump is pursuing limits on birthright citizenship by citing an 1884 Supreme Court ruling, United States v. Elk, that denied citizenship rights to Native Americans. The case involved a Native American man who attempted to vote and was rejected on the grounds that he was not a U.S. citizen, establishing a legal precedent that some groups could be born in the country but excluded from automatic citizenship. Trump's invocation of this ruling suggests an attempt to narrow the scope of the 14th Amendment's citizenship clause, which currently grants citizenship to nearly all people born on U.S. soil. The strategy relies on historical case law that many legal scholars view as inconsistent with modern constitutional interpretation and civil rights law. How the administration moves forward—whether through executive action, legislation, or litigation—will determine whether this approach gains legal traction.
What's Being Done
The administration is considering executive action, legislation, or litigation to narrow the 14th Amendment's citizenship clause.
Source Coverage Map
4 of 43 tracked sources covered this story
Following this story?
Get notified when new coverage appears
Other Sources Covering This Story
5 sourcesMultiple outlets have reported on this story. Compare perspectives from different sources.

Daughter of immigrants brings history to bear in fight for birthright citizenship - The Washington Post

In Supreme Court fight over birthright citizenship, a great-grandson hears echoes of 1898 - Reuters

Daughter of immigrants brings history to bear in fight for birthright citizenship
This article is part of a story we're tracking:
Should this be getting more attention?
You Might Have Missed
Related stories from different sources and perspectives
Civil RightsTrump’s order on birthright citizenship would harm millions, including citizens
On April 1, the Supreme Court will hear arguments on one of the most consequential immigration cases in decades. At issue is whether President Trump’s executive order restricting birthright citizenship can stand. The stakes could not be higher. If the court sides with Trump, the damage will ripple far beyond undocumented immigrants. It will affect legal visa…
PoliticsFour Problems for Trump in Birthright Citizenship Case
The president must confront a 1952 federal law, the possibility that millions will lose their citizenships, stateless foundlings and a fluid future.
PoliticsTrump casts Florida mail ballot as he pushes Congress to severely limit that voting option - AP News
<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMijgFBVV95cUxNOGNMdi05ajJ6RHE0cUtIVnNtQzNuWFUwWjN2NE1GSUMyTWo0ZUgzSDlFaVloLUFLbWJpd0tCa0puN25tMXdGWE5kNmtEVDl3STRKUDE2QmNCd0dScTRVOU1vQVp2NEJoVjM4aUxfcGFKVHM5QndlNVVBSlRTRkNiVTJzaDhKd0ttVllRcTFR?oc=5" target="_blank">Trump casts Florida mail ballot as he pushes Congress to severely limit that voting option</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">AP News</font>
Politics'We don't have an actual policy.' Supreme Court debates limits on asylum-seekers - USA Today
<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMiugFBVV95cUxPNTlzai1Eci1uTnZCRVVZRFluN2gxQ2tYUkQwTHhDWHhwM0JHVVhGTGtEQktmNjNWdjdmUHJtSUhZTEVqcjg5ZWhHS2ZPdnVQRXNCTW5neERMd0ZtOTdjbnFHYXlLcVk1RVlfXzJCektyZzVUMEpYdy04ZDhkN0tCOVhOR3hVWjlBMm5TVGd5Qkd3ODBVQmZWMUZ5Z0t4V05mSVBCbk4wYm9wdU5Fc0NFTkVmb2g1M2VBU3c?oc=5" target="_blank">'We don't have an actual policy.' Supreme Court debates limits on asylum-seekers</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">USA Today</font>
PoliticsUS Supreme Court conservatives lean toward Republican bid to limit mail-in voting - Reuters
<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMisgFBVV95cUxOX3JjeWJJX2dwT2dRbmFSck42Rmt5T045VWotRGtxZklSU1FmVTMxQVBmZnZTaGhyaGI4SnN0azRZdWU4ZDBrMVpYcHZTN3hkUGo0T2Y5SnZ6d1ltc29xN2hycU1oTHFQcGJDUnZTWE9JTG9pSzJWRlpSRnZiX3pXWV82Y2dkWjkyYllJWS1qcFhZY2NTa19xTTZrTzFYNnd4MmoybXI0dUc5X3JiOXE3ZUFn?oc=5" target="_blank">US Supreme Court weighs Republican bid to limit mail-in voting</a> <font color="#6f6f6f">Reuters</font>
Civil RightsAs Trump blocks asylum seekers, Supreme Court to decide if US must review claims
A major legal battle over the ability of asylum seekers to apply for refuge in the U.S. at ports of entry along the border with Mexico lands at the Supreme Court.

F.B.I. Said to Dig Up Old Investigative Files on Democratic Lawmaker
The urgent instructions at the Trump administration’s behest to gather and relay the files on Representative Eric Swalwell have alarmed some career law enforcement officials.
Did this story change how you see things?
Stories like this only matter when people see them. Help us get verified journalism in front of more eyes.
The Verity Ledger curates verified investigative journalism from trusted sources only.
See our sourcesMost Read This Week
Senate deal reached to cap insulin costs

'The gravest crime against humanity': What does the UN vote on slavery mean?

Pentagon will remove media offices after judge reinstates NYT's press credentials

Iran built a vast camera network to control dissent. Israel used it to track targets, AP sources say

At Pentagon Christian service, Hegseth prays for violence 'against those who deserve no mercy'




