DOJ concludes presidential records requirement unconstitutional
Quick Insights
The Bottom Line
DOJ claims Presidential Records Act violates Constitution, potentially eliminating requirements for presidents to preserve official documents.
How This Affects You
If courts adopt this legal position, future presidents would face no legal requirement to preserve or surrender official records, reducing public access to government documents that typically become available through archives and FOIA requests.
AI Summary
The Justice Department has concluded that the Presidential Records Act of 1978, which requires presidents to preserve and surrender records at the end of their term, violates the Constitution by exceeding congressional authority. The 52-page opinion, which is legally nonbinding, argues the law unconstitutionally intrudes on executive power. The finding comes amid ongoing litigation over former President Donald Trump's handling of classified documents and other presidential records at his Mar-a-Lago residence. A DOJ opinion of this nature does not constitute binding legal precedent, but it signals the administration's legal position on a statute that has governed presidential record-keeping for nearly five decades. The conclusion could influence how courts evaluate challenges to the 1978 law and reshape the legal landscape around presidential document retention.
What's Being Done
The nonbinding DOJ opinion signals the administration's legal position in ongoing litigation over Trump's document handling and could influence how courts evaluate challenges to the 1978 law.
This article is part of a story we're tracking:
Should this be getting more attention?
You Might Have Missed
Related stories from different sources and perspectives
Government TransparencyDOJ says Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional
The opinion from the Office of Legal Counsel said that because it believes the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional, President Trump does not need to comply with it.
Government TransparencyExclusive: Trump's DOJ says he's not required to turn over official records
<p><a href="https://www.axios.com/politics-policy/donald-trump" target="_blank">President Trump</a>'s Justice Department has concluded that a federal law requiring presidential records to be turned over to the government is unconstitutional, a senior White House official tells Axios.</p><p><strong>Why it matters: </strong>The finding is an indication Trump will be reluctant to give all of his official records to the National Archives at the end of his term, as presidents have done for nearly a half-century under the <a href="https://www.axios.com/2022/08/09/trump-presidential-records-fbi-warrant" target="_blank">Presidential Records Act</a> of 1978.</p><hr><ul><li>The law, passed in the post-Watergate era as a hedge against government corruption, states that every official record regarding a president's decisions or policies belongs to the U.S. government, not the president.</li></ul><p><strong>Trump has shown </strong>that he disagrees with the law.</p><ul><li>When he left office i...
Government TransparencyJustice Dept. says the Presidential Records Act is ‘unconstitutional’ - The Washington Post
Government TransparencyTrump does not have to turn over presidential records, Justice Department says - NBC News
Government TransparencyChristie: Blanche ‘obliterating’ DOJ’s reputation
Former federal prosecutor Chris Christie (R) on Sunday said Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche is “obliterating” the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) reputation after the official touted the mass firing of employees tied to President Trump’s past indictments. “We didn’t obliterate the Iran nuclear program, obviously, in June — but he is obliterating his reputation and…
Government TransparencyThe Intercept’s Press Freedom Defense Fund Leads Cohort Fighting Trump’s Unconstitutional Media Attacks
A cohort of 42 media organizations and press freedom advocates filed an amicus brief supporting court decisions against Trump’s attempts to censor the press and legal profession. The post The Intercept’s Press Freedom Defense Fund Leads Cohort Fighting Trump’s Unconstitutional Media Attacks appeared first on The Intercept .
Trump's VA killed a home loan program. Vets are now losing their homes because of it
Foreclosures on VA loans are at their highest level in a decade. VA has a fix but it is months away and could still leave vets worse off than most other homeowners.
Did this story change how you see things?
Stories like this only matter when people see them. Help us get verified journalism in front of more eyes.
The Verity Ledger curates verified investigative journalism from trusted sources only.
See our sourcesMost Read This Week
'The gravest crime against humanity': What does the UN vote on slavery mean?
After 16 years and $8 billion, the military's new GPS software still doesn't work
US paves way for private assets to be included in 401(k) retirement plans - Reuters
The Justice Department plans to share sensitive voter data with Homeland Security
Trump administration scales back on asylum crackdown, sources say
