Election Records Handed Over to the FBI in Maricopa County, Arizona, Could Be Fatally Flawed, Experts Say

ProPublica
by Jen Fifield
March 12, 2026
2 views
5 min read

Quick Insights

The Bottom Line

Experts say Maricopa County election data given to the FBI is likely flawed, risking public confidence.

How This Affects You

Public confidence in election security and future legal proceedings could be undermined due to flawed election data.

AI Summary

The FBI received digital data related to a partisan audit of Maricopa County, Arizona's 2020 election from Arizona Senate President Warren Petersen this week, not actual ballots. This data, which may include scans and photos of ballots, originated from the Cyber Ninjas firm, which conducted an audit funded by Trump allies and privately admitted its ballot recounts were "screwy." Election experts, including Ryan Macias, state that any investigation based on this data would be "fatally flawed" and risks "further degradation of public confidence." Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes believes the contractor's sloppy procedures make it unlikely a court would accept these records as evidence of irregularities.

What's Being Done

The FBI received digital data from a partisan audit of Maricopa County's 2020 election.

Source Coverage Map

2 of 43 tracked sources covered this story

Overlooked Story
5% coverage
Did Not Cover (41)
ICIJ97AP World News96AP News96AP US News96AP Top News96+36 more

Following this story?

Get notified when new coverage appears

Other Sources Covering This Story

1 source

Multiple outlets have reported on this story. Compare perspectives from different sources.

Should this be getting more attention?

You Might Have Missed

Related stories from different sources and perspectives

Top Arizona lawmaker says he's complied with a subpoena for 2020 election records
Government Transparency

Top Arizona lawmaker says he's complied with a subpoena for 2020 election records

Arizona's state Senate president says he has complied with a subpoena he received last week seeking records from a flawed, Republican-led review of the 2020 election in Maricopa County.

NPRMar 9
Trump administration widens its 2020 election probe as it obtains records from Arizona
Politics

Trump administration widens its 2020 election probe as it obtains records from Arizona

The Republican leader of Arizona's state Senate said Monday he has handed over records related to the 2020 presidential election to the FBI in the latest sign that the Trump administration is acting on the president's longstanding falsehoods about a race he lost to Democrat Joe Biden.

PBS NewsHourMar 10
The Trump administration widens its probe of the 2020 election as it obtains records from Arizona - AP News
Politics

The Trump administration widens its probe of the 2020 election as it obtains records from Arizona - AP News

<a href="https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMioAFBVV95cUxNSkQtN0tNN1ZhVmZwZ2RwS3JTeVdKbGI0RmFDcWFKN0JLNjlHNjhsVGI5RkNyMzhLeUJTZGJXNWNhM3h6SklJVXdvRkJqZDhCLUhMY3IzbVFvaGRCWUxrbnNWM1VIajVDLTZrSnBUTXhkMnk4R1ZwM0o2OTdrWmRqcGxLMVZQbk1LejBscUNBZXBLZE1fWnBDQ0F3a3BjaXlp?oc=5" target="_blank">The Trump administration widens its probe of the 2020 election as it obtains records from Arizona</a>&nbsp;&nbsp;<font color="#6f6f6f">AP News</font>

AP NewsMar 10
This DHS Official Oversees the Security of Federal Elections. He Wants to Ban Voting Machines.
Politics

This DHS Official Oversees the Security of Federal Elections. He Wants to Ban Voting Machines.

The post This DHS Official Oversees the Security of Federal Elections. He Wants to Ban Voting Machines. appeared first on ProPublica .

ProPublicaMar 14
She was an active 69-year-old, but records said she was dying in hospice
Health

She was an active 69-year-old, but records said she was dying in hospice

A CBS News analysis of records for every hospice operating in Los Angeles County finds indications of fraud are growing. Adam Yamaguchi reports.

CBS NewsMar 10
Democrats flip New Hampshire House seat in special election
Politics

Democrats flip New Hampshire House seat in special election

Democrats on Tuesday flipped a state in the New Hampshire House, adding to the party’s string of special election wins as the midterm cycle kicks into high gear.  Democrat Bobbi Boudman defeated Republican Dale Fincher for Carroll County House District 7, according to a projection from Decision Desk HQ, filling a vacancy after Republican Glenn…

The HillMar 11
Read Next
FCC chair threatens to throttle news broadcasts over ‘hoaxes’ about Iran war
Government Transparency

FCC chair threatens to throttle news broadcasts over ‘hoaxes’ about Iran war

<p>Brendan Carr posts that he may cancel spectrum permits of ‘mainstream news’ outlets for ‘misleading’ coverage</p><p>The <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/trump-administration">Trump administration</a>’s communications licensing tsar fired a warning shot over the US broadcasting industry Saturday, threatening to cancel the spectrum permits of broadcasters pushing what he termed “hoaxes and news distortions”.</p><p>Federal Communications Commission (FCC) chair Brendan Carr posted on social media that broadcasters running “fake news – have a chance now to correct course before their license renewals come up. The law is clear. Broadcasters must operate in the public interest, and they will lose their licenses if they do not.”</p> <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/14/fcc-broadcast-permits-iran-war-news">Continue reading...</a>

Continue reading

Did this story change how you see things?

Stories like this only matter when people see them. Help us get verified journalism in front of more eyes.

Share this story

Get the daily digest

Save for later

The Verity Ledger curates verified investigative journalism from trusted sources only.

See our sources